“Why did you put it in the Vietnamese American community where people don't speak the language? You think they can't protest? You think they don't know the law or their rights?”
Mimi Nguyen, Katrina FEMA Volunteer & Activist
Versailles, New Orleans East, LA Chef Menteur Landfill, 2005–2006
More than three decades ago, Vietnamese refugees began to settle in Versailles, a community in eastern New Orleans.
When the Katrina devastated New Orleans in 2005, Versailles residents rebuilt their neighborhood faster than other damaged neighborhoods in the city. Community leaders put together an ambitious redevelopment plan for Versailles, including its own senior housing, a cultural center, and an urban community farm and market.
With all of these great plans moving forward, Versailles residents found themselves threatened by a new toxic landfill slated to open just two miles away without proper environmental studies conducted.
Forced out of Vietnam by the war 30 years ago, many residents felt their homes were being taken away from them once again.
Read Full Story
REBUILDING THREATENED
Six weeks after Hurricane Katrina, some residents of Versailles came back and started rebuilding. Urban farming was key to helping the community become among the first to return to flood-ravaged homes and restart their lives after Katrina, with little assistance from government officials. It took many months for a grocery store to reopen anywhere nearby, but urban farming provided them sustenance along with a sense of calm and cultural connection in trying times. Further community connections were reestablished as Father Vien began holding regular Sunday Mass; as word got out more and more residents returned.
In early 2006, under pressure to remove the tons of debris piled up on New Orleans’ streets, Mayor Nagin signed an executive order to locate a landfill that would hold a third of that waste less than two miles from Versailles, and less than a mile from the community’s new urban farming plot.
The landfill was hastily opened with Nagin’s emergency powers, bypassing the usual community input and permitting processes required for such a facility. Residents and conservationists concerned about the adjacent Bayou Savage wetland preserve (the largest urban wildlife refuge in the country, with 23,000 acres of marshland) had defeated previous efforts to open a landfill there, but the fast-tracked post-Katrina process sidestepped any opposition.
The aftermath In August 2005, the storm surge created by Hurricane Katrina breached the levees of New Orleans and flooded 80 percent of the city. The lowest-lying areas were especially hard hit, with miles of devastation caused by wind and water. The Village de l’Est in East New Orleans, home to some 6,000 Vietnamese Americans, was one of the destroyed neighborhoods.
Commonly known as Versailles, this small area has perhaps the highest concentration of Vietnamese Americans in the U.S. today due to mass refugee relocation thirty years ago. While the storm devastated the Versailles neighborhood, it ultimately had the opposite effect on its residents.
The Vietnamese Americans were a quiet community, barely noticed outside of East New Orleans. Self-sufficient and industrious, they tended lush garden plots, ran a weekly farmer’s market, built homes, bought cars, and generally achieved the American dream. The center of their community was — and still is — Mary Queen of Vietnam Catholic Church, and its pastor and leader, Father Vien, who joined the congregation in 2003.
When Hurricane Katrina destroyed all that they had built, it was an emotionally wrenching time. When the flood waters covered their community and they were forced to evacuate, those who had once fled their country in boats now found themselves in boats again, looking for refuge.
A Village Called Versailles
Excerpts from A Village Called Versailles Film Guide
S. Leo Chiang, Director of A Village Called Versailles
When Katrina devastated New Orleans, members of the Vietnamese American community of Versailles were among the first to return, with almost 90% of their population rebuilding their homes.
GRASSROOTS IMPACT
A visit from environmental lawyer Joel Waltzer informed Father Vien that the Chef Menteur landfill would be a dumping ground not just for benign construction debris, but for any and all household and building waste, including toxic materials.
“It’s essentially the guts of your house, all your personal possessions,”said Joel Waltzer, a lawyer representing landfill opponents. “Electronics, personal-care products, cleaning solutions, pesticides, fertilizers, bleach.” Normally, construction and demolition landfills are not required to have liners, since they are filled with dry, relatively benign waste. Katrina demolition waste is a different story: it includes the remains of homes soaked for days in toxic floodwater.
Versailles residents were outraged and staged demonstrations at City Hall and at the landfill site. After many civil invitations and non-violent protests, they still heard very little from the local government, and nothing from Mayor Nagin.
“Maybe we’re not the right kind of people he wanted to return,” Father Vien said.
When their actions failed to close the facility, the residents took their fight to the state legislature and the courts. In August of 2006, the community finally obtained a court order that shut down Chef Menteur.
National Network & Policy-making
The Vietnamese American community of Versailles made a remarkable comeback. Today, 90 percent of its residents have returned, and the Chef Menteur landfill remains closed. Residents of Versailles formed the grassroots organization Mary Queen of Vietnam Community Development Corporation (MQVCDC) “to preserve and promote our unique diversity and improving the quality of life of residents in the Greater New Orleans area, beginning in New Orleans East.” In 2008, one of their own scored an upset election victory to become the first Vietnamese American to serve in the U.S. House of Representatives.
Residents of Versailles continue to make their voices heard through a grassroots organization created to preserve and promote New Orleans’ unique diversity and improving residents’ quality of life.
Today Versailles' urban garden is thriving thanks to local leaders like Father Vien and the overwhelming support of the entire community.
Versailles Analyzing Trends
Success of the people Protest nonviolently through blockades Involve entire community Delegate leadership roles to youth Attend government meetings Read carefully over legal documentation Hold state accountable Conduct environmental studies Harness media attention Create national activism support system
Failure of the state Shortcut political protocol Withhold information Distribute waste unevenly over state Target a minority community Offer few hosting benefits Exclude community from decisions Disregard promises